Should I Repair or Replace My Air Compressor Pump?

February 4, 2021

The pump in an air compressor performs the crucial function of moving fluid from one place to another within the unit. A damaged or malfunctioning pump will negatively impact the compressor’s operation and likely require a repair or replacement.

Air Compressor Pump Repair: Pros and Cons

In many cases, repairing a compressor pump provides a more practical and cost-effective solution than a full replacement. For instance, if your compressor is a newer model with low service hours, a repair could be a relatively simple project. You shouldn’t have trouble acquiring the right parts for a recently released product. If it’s a smaller job, you may also have the resources to complete the job in-house to minimize the cost.

On the other hand, if you’ve experienced previous issues with the pump, repairing it may not provide a viable long-term solution. A complete pump rebuild might be more affordable than a replacement, although this is a labor-intensive project that requires multiple parts and components. These products could also be hard to find if you have an older pump. You may face substantial downtime until you’re able to finish the rebuild and install the pump.

Air Compressor Pump Replacement: Pros and Cons

If your broken compressor pump is severely damaged, a replacement could be the best solution. A new pump ensures reliable performance and reduces the likelihood of future repairs, at least in the short term. It also makes sense for high-demand applications where the pump and compressor experience heavy use.

Conversely, buying a new pump is typically much more expensive than repairing or rebuilding an existing unit. If your company is operating on a tight budget, a brand-new pump might not be a good financial fit. However, if you own an older air compressor model, replacing the pump may only be postponing the inevitable. It could be only a matter of time until the compressor experiences other mechanical issues besides the pump that will require you to upgrade the entire unit.

Repair vs. Replacement: Which Option Is Right for You?

For many companies, the decision of whether to repair or replace a pump comes down to cost. When determining the overall cost, it’s important to weigh the upfront expense of a new pump vs. the money it will save in the form of lower operating, repair and utility costs over time. For a heavy-use environment, a full replacement will likely be more cost-effective in the long run.

Downtime is another consideration. Consider how long you can go without a properly functioning air compressor before it causes a substantial and costly interruption to your operating processes. A replacement often provides a faster solution than a pump rebuild or extensive repair job.

Contact Quincy Compressor for Expert Guidance

If you’re having difficulty deciding whether to repair or replace air compressor pumps, contact Quincy Compressor. We’ll use our compressed air expertise to point you in the right direction.